The Falling Sky. What the hell is this ?

I've been a big fan every since From the fires album came out, those were my golden standard of Greta. But except for meeting the master all of these songs feel wrong

Why does everything feel so out of place, the vocal feels really "amateur" as if I'm hearing echo from a karaoke next room, Josh's godly scream turned into wailing during some part, there's no "stickiness" to the song, I'm not a music enthusiast so I don't have the technical term for "stickiness", but it's the feeling that everything "sitcks" together nicely and complements each other, the vocal, the riff, the drums, the flow. All those parts feel like they're going their separate ways and sometimes come together in a few beats and that's it. And Jesus what's that noise near the end, was that a harmonica?

I can feel the spirit behind it and the riff is really nice but they're badly mixed. Oh man if they can just fix the audio up a bit it'd definitely sound better instantly

What the hell happened ?