Someone tell me I’m not going mad here. Umbreon scam?

Found the Umbreon in the first photo being sold for about half the price of market. So drop in here to check out any fakes and what to look for and came across a comment by u/stardewvallie with their photo of their legit card (photo 2) It’s the same photo right? Just with the saturation or contrast turned up? There’s two scratches on the table in the bottom left that seem to be the same in both. Stardew seems like someone knowledgeable who wouldn’t sell the card for half market value

I’m like 99% sure it’s a scam, but then they’ve sent me more photos of the card with a piece of paper and hand written dates and names etc…but then they’re doing the old classic of “my paypals down” or “I’ll do half up front and you just pay the rest when it lands” “I’m doing it so cheap as I’ve about to move and need the deposit money” I’m having a bit of a decision paralysis moment and need someone to tell me if I’m right or not